Vinny is too low Lady K is too loud

3 Pepper sauce is where it’s at

I pulled my support for the creep off Patreon and the WATP Patreon when Karl decided to start shilling for cops. He’s not a podcaster anymore, just a full time bootlicker. Back the blue, until it happens to you. Carl is in a band and for sure drinks and drives when they play gigs (if he doesn’t he’s a pozer), he has also mentioned on numerous occasions that he uses controlled substances every once and awhile. Only a matter of time before his luck runs out and the same cops who he invests so much time running PR cover for bring their boot down on him. And he deserves it too. P.s. Vinny is a talentless hack and total NPC who only has the most obvious normie takes about everything. Totally incapable of being funny, interesting, unpredictable, or healthy and will be a victim of heart disease undoubtedly meeting his demise before he’s 50 but, hey, pizza is yummy yummy yummy! Right guys? Useless eater.

Why is Vinnie so annoying?

Join Vinny and Karl as they laugh like school girls over the deaths of school girls and other grizzly crime stories.

Excellent program..

Listening to this. Proof anyone can start a podcast.

I need to listen to something while I rub lotion on my legs. Which means I have to take my pants off...alot. So when I do this, I like to listen to random podcast. I found the Creep Off and had no idea what was going on till half way in. Im hooked now. I now put lotion on my legs more often then I should just so I can listen to Creep Off. My floor is all crusty and white but its worth it to listen to these two 70 yr olds talk about random things. Its a plus that Jess is there to. Shes the best and if she leaves, im going to stop my lotion time. If you are looking for a podcast to laugh at and be creeped out at the same time, then the Creep Off is just for you. Tho if your a normal person, I would pass on this podcast. You are not worthry of the Creep Off. Now if you dont mind, I need to buy some more lotion. Much loves. Buffalo Bill. HAIL JESS

He was trying to play along with Blind Mike’s joke and started singing a Veggie Tales song. Loser. That is all.

This is a vanity project by a club-toothed, snaggle-footed boomer that serves as a pretext for him to hit on young review girls. There’s also an XL pizza containment system on the podcast. He’s there to click buttons, I think. For some reason, they talk about criminals while sober.

Have you ever listened to a true crime podcast and thought, "this show needs more victim blaming, jokes about infanticide, and tips to criminals on how to evade authorities?" Well, then, you're in luck. The Creep Off is an irreverent take on the true crime genre, with a twist that turns heinous headlines into a deranged competition. If you're the type of person who doesn't shy away from gallows humor, then check it out. Just remember to BleachBit your Zune player after listening, otherwise you might end up on an FBI watch list.

Decent show, I give the review girl three episodes before the host creepy Carl gets her to post nudes

Karla and VinNAE don’t drink wine, do the bare minimum of research and don’t even read Wikipedia verbatim. They even have the gall to criticize real true crime podcasts that do. Very disappointing

Such as one from Rochester to Gary, Indiana.

I don’t like it.

I don’t know how anybody can listen to this crap

True crime podcasting should be more like American Crimes in my opinion, that man is truly the GOAT. Short of that true crime shows are meant for vacuous white women drinking wine and using extreme vocal fry. Give up now and save yourself any future embarrassment, your podcast stinks! See you in Rochester…don’t call me back!

Karl and Blind Mike are a great combination. So much better. Oh hi Vinny.

Just great fun!

Great idea for a bonus show would be victim blaming where you two guys take a crime and tell everyone how it is the victims fault

But for stupid people.

It’s revolting how much these hosts mock and trivialize horrible tragedies, all for a few laughs.

Even with Vinnie it’s still funny

I’m still waiting for the multi-episode special about the mystery of PJ Philliam’s murder. Get with the program.

I feel like I’m going to get put in Facebook jail, or real jail when I listen to this podcast. Carl’s free use of the R word makes me feel like an American. You’re both oddly attractive, yet, Artie Lange is my Brad Pitt. I love an unattractive comedy genius, and I’m not comparing you schlubs to the great Mr. Lange so go F yourselves.

Yankee Doodle Doo is an ancestor of Scooby-Doo, owned by McBaggy Rogers, Shaggy's ancestor. Arrived in America on the Mayflower. Physical appearance He looks very much like Scooby-Doo (possibly being his ancestor), but in a pilgrim costume and had a grim facial expression. Personality Like his master, he appears sour-tempered. History The New Scooby and Scrappy Doo Show He appears only in an illustration in a book, since he came to America with his master on the Mayflower. I’m

I know that it is “cool” To write snarky comments in iTunes reviews, all the kids are doing it, but I actually love this podcast. Sorry for being a “boomer” I guess.

Roy and Ricky Masterson have way too many podcasts. It’s almost like they are having a competition for who can podcast the most.

You guys are from Rochester it’s the same thing. I call it Crotch fester. Now that’s comedy. Meet me at Margaritaville in Destiny and let’s throw hands. We can go kart afterward.

Karl’s here, but that isn’t Kevinnor Andy!?!? And where’s what’s-her-name?!?!? Why are you talking about creeps?!?? Am I in the wrong podcast? Dammit!

One of the hosts is incapable of pronouncing the word exactly and for some reason, is obsessed with the age of consent in New York. The other host doesn’t care about anything except pizza and attention to detail. 10/10 would recommend.

9 minute, 9 minute, 9 minute podcast. Sorry, was thinking about the theme song of my favorite WATP media podcast. Anyway i love the fact you supplement the bachelor content with creeps, The Scunt Parade segment rules. I wish you could do something like my other favorite podcast, on Fridays they do a patreon only show called Drinks by the Dumpster and pretend you need to pay for it but post it on youtube for free every week because the host is a mongoloid. Love you guys, really dig the segments with Vic Henley and Carl ruiz, Five stars

Trash the whole contest angle. Make the scum parade the main segment and the main creep the bonus segment. Karl is really corny in here but not watp.

Wokester Vinnie P tries desperately to bottom feed off of Who Are These Podcasts? Success. Shameful. Pat Mike would not approve

I don’t understand the contest concept of the show. Which child murderer is creepier? What are we even talking about? How is that determined exactly and why are people voting for this? Only the most vile creepos will enjoy this.

Did you see Tiger King and Don't F**k with Cats? Are you able to read Wikipedia? Congratulations, you are one step ahead of the bumbling hosts: Blobby Magoo and Teef. It's clear from the outset these guys just dabble in true crime as goof. If you like competent, well-researched, and depthful recountings of henious crimes, this is not the show for you. If you like podcasts in general, this show is not for you. In fact, nobody should listen to this show. Ever.

This show is almost as good as do you party. If you love creeps this is the show for you it’s hosted by one of the funniest comedians in western New York and a guy named Vinnie

Just wanted to hear Cobra Commander read that title. Also I find Karl very attractive. Now THAT’S creepy.

I tried it for the creeps, but I’m staying for the Cobra Commander!

The creep off is absolutely fantastic! If you’d like to follow along with the fat one, search for his creep on last podcast on the left. If you’d like to follow along with the fat sounding one, google “______ arrested” and click on the first result. Anyway, review me back!

It’s just sad that Nick Kroll and Eric Stonestreet would have to forgo their TV careers and sink to this new low of podcasting.

I thought the wheel of consequences was to punish the hosts! These Nick Bate songs are for the birds. Oof

The main guy is basically a sadistic dilbert. The other dude has a heavy bag on his neck that the dilbert dude keeps soccer kicking.

This show reminds me of eating at Taco Bell as a grad student. It feels good at the time, but the next day your hangover is only trumped by the bad food. Vinny and Karl are equivalent to the Biblical Four Horseman, and Vinny makes up for 3 of them. Karl’s sense of humor makes the Brief Case sound like Dave Chapelle. Sick, disgusting, and Jack Dorsey needs to ban this show… please.

This is the best true crime podcast I have every heard. True crime is such a hard genre that many people are not willing to attempt it. It's one of those subjects that people are really not that interested in but there are some people that like it. I hope this genre catches on and more people produce true crime podcast.

This show has no Vic, therefore this show is good

Play more clown music

Nothing like taking a pair of awful people and trying to argue who is the worst. Great way to laugh at the worst of society. I look forward to this show going on till at least episode 77, when inevitably a feud will drive the two hosts apart and result in a laughable multimillion dollar lawsuit.

“I would rather be caught with child porn than The Last Jedi.” -Vinnie

Be less fat. Also Karl, be less loud.