There are much better TIU podcasts out there. This crew often makes mistakes talk over each other, are loud and disjointed. I’ve had to step away from a few Facebook pages because people write outlandish theories and obviously don’t pay attention to the show, this podcast has the same feel. Don’t waste your time!

It bothers me that you guys often get your facts wrong about the show. Specifically, when you keep referring to “a bomb” being dropped in season 4 about Sophie and Kevin being married...you guys should probably go back and rewatch the series from the beginning because Sophie was introduced in the first season as Kevin’s ex wife and they mention their marriage and divorce several times throughout every season of the show. I was a bit shocked that you guys would all forget that. In the first episode we see Sophie in season one, when he comes to her door, she says, “my ex husband, who I haven’t seen in 12 years shows up at my door...” and then at the diner the next day, she says, “where we left off?? Where we left off is you cheating on me and ruining our marriage.” It’s never been a secret or “bomb” that they were married because it was disclosed from the first moment we meet Sophie in season one. The only thing that might be considered a “bomb” is when we find out that they were married right out of high school, but we’ve always known they were married. That’s really been bothering me because I’ve heard Candace especially referencing this as a “bomb” dropped in season 4. Please get your facts straight if you’re going to make a podcast about this show!

I listen to his podcast really just to see the difference between what they have to say vs another TIU podcast Listen to. Nice to hear different perspectives. Sadly this group doesn’t always get the facts straight they confused Philadelphia with Pittsburgh. They didn’t know why the episode was called Clouds. I understand you are podcasting post show but you have been off several times on things. May want to google some things before you say them. It is entertaining & like to hear the tissues moments because I’m a crier.

I can’t get enough of y’all. I love this show.

Absolutely love This Is Us....and love this podcast as well! I usually watch the episode twice before I listen to the podcast, and they still point out things I didn’t notice or help me look at something in a different way. Look forward to this one every week!

I’ve been hook on this is is since the first episode. I’m SO HAPPY I found this podcast. Love y’all’s beak downs and opinions. Keep it up guys!

My GOD stop saying like. I had to turn it off because it made me ragey!

I don’t know why I keep trying to listen to these panelists. I keep trying to give them the benefit of the doubt, but my ears always hurt every time I listen to their commentary. I personally don’t think these panelists are considerate and qualified enough to discuss the type of issues the show brings up. They claim to have sensitivity to different opinions, but don’t show it. Doesn’t help that I disagree with every single one of their views. It honestly seems like they found a random bunch of fans on the street and asked them to start a podcast on this show. I just started watching the new review of the Kevin episode, but shut it off after 5 minutes when they already forgot what happened in the episode.... doesn’t tell me they take their job seriously if they forget what had just happened on the show. I’m sorry, I really wanted to like these panelists and hear some of their insight, but I will never take any of them and their insight seriously with the way it’s presented.

I love this show. I get so much out of the insight of the panelists. But the podcast version can be very difficult to listen to. The ads come in out of nowhere, cutting a speaker off mid sentence, and the ads are SO LOUD compared to the show it scares me or hurts my ears. Every time an ad comes on like that, I consider not listening to the show anymore, but I love what you have to say so I press on. If a smoother transition to the ad is impossible, just having the volume the same would make a world of difference

Love the subject, but might be more enjoyable with fewer panelists/hosts. Also, it’s great for a “fellow viewer” kind of experience, but would be even better if one of the panelists did research (even just IMDB) to know the details about characters and actors. It’s a solid 4 stars though! 👍🏼

They have some good commentary which is why I listen. There are too many people talking and shouting at the same time. It gets loud and off topic at times.

Too chaotic for my taste—hosts are often loud, boisterous, laughing about silly stuff and side talk which to me detracts from a real discussion of the episode. They do seem to be enjoying themselves so I guess that’s a good thing. But I’m out.

I love listening to this show every week! Danny, Paris, Candice, and Haley have so much fun talking about the show and it makes me love it even more! I also love watching them make predictions and seeing the rest get so into it, makes me know they love the show just as much as I do!

The host are constantly make predictions or talking about facts the the producers and creators have already discussed. For instance Dan has said several time Madison and Kevin will not get together. They have also stated that the flash forward from the 3rd season finale was 10-12 years in the future so Baby Jack wouldn’t be with his fiancé on the way to Kevin’s house.

This podcast would be 100 times better if the hosts would stop talking over each other! I have to shut it off because it just sounds like chaos. I really want to like it but...

The people who went to Canada to avoid the draft were pardoned after the war so they could return home. I remember my father was furious about the pardons because so many Black men and died in Vietnam because they couldn't afford to get to Canada or get out of being drafted.

When the host aren’t Marisa and the southern girl I love this podcast. Marisa just has negative opinions and criticism of the how which gets aggravating and the other chick is too much, Amber and the other girls are great just wish they’d let each other talk without talking over each other and do the recap without getting side tracked

This was my first time listening and I am wondering do the hosts even know what they are talking about! Franco Harris is a Pittsburgh Steeler, he has nothing to do with Beth or Zoe’s characters. Come on! Do some research! There was an actual clip with Franco Harris in the show! A simple Google search will tell you he is a football icon. As for Kevin and Zoe’s trip, isn’t it obvious that they are going to Vietnam? These hosts ramble and talk nonsense!

This podcast gives me a headache. Everybody talks over each other and they don't listen to what each other says. They seem like nice people, but the way they communicate is haphazard and not well thought out. It feels very emotional and spontaneous. I do not gain much insight after listening to it, nor do I share their views.

Randall had a job @ an executive level ... In in the field Actuary Science ...It deals with statistical methods, math, models & data ... It is used to assess risk in several industries & professions

Marisa's voice isn't podcast friendly though.

During the discussion the girls were wondering what Toby did for a living and thought he was a limo driver and wondered how he was home all the time. I thought I saw a tweet that he responded to and said he was an IT guy.

You ladies have great insight into the characters on the show. However, you never seem to actually "recap". You tend to start at the big moment of the show and then discuss it with bits and pieces of the rest of the episode thrown in. A beginning to end recap would be nice. But you do a great service to a great show.

Amber and sometimes Shannon, it is really difficult to hear you on the podcast most of the time. Maybe speak into the mic more? Thanks! As to theories about Jack's death...don't forget Kate's fear of flying and one of the boys destroying his model planes...maybe his death has to do with flying? Pretty good summaries overall.

Like their commentary! But Marissa Serafinis voice is annoying.

When I first saw the trailer for NBC new show This Is Us, I thought it was a sci-fi show. I remembered the statistic about 18 Million people in the world having the same birthday. I thought these people were going to be swapping bodies/lives somehow. Eagerly I watch the first episode. Nobody swap body and I missed the last scene at the hospital. So, I thought well it took awhile for Heros to get going; maybe the next episode will have the sci-fi element. I check afterbuzz and tune in on your discussion; sadly I missed the last bit of your aftershow too. However, I heard your praises and decided to give This Is Us a chance. I missed the recap at the begging of the 2nd episode. I was totally confused for a few heartbeat until I figured out the relationship. This show is Genius!!! I was hooked!!! Thank you team!!!